Based on sequencing data, norovirus (NoV) recombinants have been described, but no experimental evidence of recombination in NoVs has been documented. Using the murine norovirus (MNV) model, we investigated the occurrence of genetic recombination between two co-infecting wild-type MNV isolates in RAW cells. The design of a PCR-based genotyping tool allowed accurate discrimination between the parental genomes and the detection of a viable recombinant MNV (Rec MNV) in the progeny viruses. Genetic analysis of Rec MNV identified a homologous-recombination event located at the ORF1–ORF2 overlap. Rec MNV exhibited distinct growth curves and produced smaller plaques than the wild-type MNV in RAW cells. Here, we demonstrate experimentally that MNV undergoes homologous recombination at the previously described recombination hot spot for NoVs, suggesting that the MNV model might be suitable for in vitro studies of NoV recombination. Moreover, the results show that exchange of genetic material between NoVs can generate viruses with distinct biological properties from the parental viruses.
Ambert-Balay, K., Bon, F., Le Guyader, F., Pothier, P. & Kohli, E.(2005). Characterization of new recombinant noroviruses. J Clin Microbiol43, 5179–5186.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Bruggink, L. D. & Marshall, J. A.(2009). Molecular and epidemiological features of GIIb norovirus outbreaks in Victoria, Australia, 2002–2005. J Med Virol81, 1652–1660.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Bull, R. A., Hansman, G. S., Clancy, L. E., Tanaka, M. M., Rawlinson, W. D. & White, P. A.(2005). Norovirus recombination in ORF1/ORF2 overlap. Emerg Infect Dis11, 1079–1085.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Bull, R. A., Tanaka, M. M. & White, P. A.(2007). Norovirus recombination. J Gen Virol88, 3347–3359.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Chuang, C. K. & Chen, W. J.(2009). Experimental evidence that RNA recombination occurs in the Japanese encephalitis virus. Virology394, 286–297.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Cooper, P. D.(1968). A genetic map of poliovirus temperature-sensitive mutants. Virology35, 584–596.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Coyne, K. P., Reed, F. C., Porter, C. J., Dawson, S., Gaskell, R. M. & Radford, A. D.(2006). Recombination of Feline calicivirus within an endemically infected cat colony. J Gen Virol87, 921–926.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Fan, J., Negroni, M. & Robertson, D. L.(2007). The distribution of HIV-1 recombination breakpoints. Infect Genet Evol7, 717–723.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Fukuda, S., Sasaki, Y., Takao, S. & Seno, M.(2008). Recombinant norovirus implicated in gastroenteritis outbreaks in Hiroshima Prefecture, Japan. J Med Virol80, 921–928.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Giraudo, A. T., Gomes, I., de Mello, P. A., Beck, E., La Torre, J. L., Scodeller, E. A. & Bergmann, I. E.(1988). Behavior of intertypic recombinants between virulent and attenuated aphthovirus strains in tissue culture and cattle. J Virol62, 3789–3794.
[Google Scholar]
Gomes, K. A., Stupka, J. A., Gomez, J. & Parra, G. I.(2007). Molecular characterization of calicivirus strains detected in outbreaks of gastroenteritis in Argentina. J Med Virol79, 1703–1709.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Hall, T. A.(1999). BioEdit: a user friendly biological sequence alignment editor and analysis program for Windows 95/98/NT. Nucleic Acids Symp Ser41, 95–98.
[Google Scholar]
Hansman, G. S., Takeda, N., Oka, T., Oseto, M., Hedlund, K. O. & Katayama, K.(2005). Intergenogroup recombination in sapoviruses. Emerg Infect Dis11, 1916–1920.
[Google Scholar]
Hyde, J. L., Sosnovtsev, S. V., Green, K. Y., Wobus, C., Virgin, H. W., IV & Mackenzie, J. M.(2009). Mouse norovirus replication is associated with virus-induced vesicle clusters originating from membranes derived from the secretory pathway. J Virol83, 9709–9719.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Jiang, X., Espul, C., Zhong, W. M., Cuello, H. & Matson, D. O.(1999). Characterization of a novel human calicivirus that may be a naturally occurring recombinant. Arch Virol144, 2377–2387.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Karst, S. M., Wobus, C. E., Lay, M., Davidson, J. & Virgin, H. W., IV(2003). STAT1-dependent innate immunity to a Norwalk-like virus. Science299, 1575–1578.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Kirkegaard, K. & Baltimore, D.(1986). The mechanism of RNA recombination in poliovirus. Cell47, 433–443.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Lai, M. M.(1992). RNA recombination in animal and plant viruses. Microbiol Rev56, 61–79.
[Google Scholar]
Larsen, F., Gundersen, G., Lopez, R. & Prydz, H.(1992). CpG islands as gene markers in the human genome. Genomics13, 1095–1107.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Lilliefors, H. W.(1967). On the Kolmogorov–Smirnov test for normality with mean and variance unknown. J Am Stat Assoc62, 399–402.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Lole, K. S., Bollinger, R. C., Paranjape, R. S., Gadkari, D., Kulkarni, S. S., Novak, N. G., Ingersoll, R., Sheppard, H. W. & Ray, S. C.(1999). Full-length human immunodeficiency virus type 1 genomes from subtype C-infected seroconverters in India, with evidence of intersubtype recombination. J Virol73, 152–160.
[Google Scholar]
Martella, V., Campolo, M., Lorusso, E., Cavicchio, P., Camero, M., Bellacicco, A. L., Decaro, N., Elia, G., Greco, G. & other authors(2007). Norovirus in captive lion cub (Panthera leo). Emerg Infect Dis13, 1071–1073.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Martella, V., Lorusso, E., Decaro, N., Elia, G., Radogna, A., D'Abramo, M., Desario, C., Cavalli, A., Corrente, M. & other authors(2008). Detection and molecular characterization of a canine norovirus. Emerg Infect Dis14, 1306–1308.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Martella, V., Decaro, N., Lorusso, E., Radogna, A., Moschidou, P., Amorisco, F., Lucente, M. S., Desario, C., Mari, V. & other authors(2009). Genetic heterogeneity and recombination in canine noroviruses. J Virol83, 11391–11396.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Martin, D. P., van der Walt, E., Posada, D. & Rybicki, E. P.(2005). The evolutionary value of recombination is constrained by genome modularity. PLoS Genet1, e51.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Mauroy, A., Scipioni, A., Mathijs, E., Thys, C. & Thiry, E.(2009). Molecular detection of kobuviruses and recombinant noroviruses in cattle in continental Europe. Arch Virol154, 1841–1845.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
McCahon, D. & Slade, W. R.(1981). A sensitive method for the detection and isolation of recombinants of foot-and-mouth disease virus. J Gen Virol53, 333–342.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Meurens, F., Keil, G. M., Muylkens, B., Gogev, S., Schynts, F., Negro, S., Wiggers, L. & Thiry, E.(2004). Interspecific recombination between two ruminant alphaherpesviruses, bovine herpesviruses 1 and 5. J Virol78, 9828–9836.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Muylkens, B., Meurens, F., Schynts, F., de Fays, K., Pourchet, A., Thiry, J., Vanderplasschen, A., Antoine, N. & Thiry, E.(2006). Biological characterization of bovine herpesvirus 1 recombinants possessing the vaccine glycoprotein E negative phenotype. Vet Microbiol113, 283–291.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Muylkens, B., Farnir, F., Meurens, F., Schynts, F., Vanderplasschen, A., Georges, M. & Thiry, E.(2009). Coinfection with two closely related alphaherpesviruses results in a highly diversified recombination mosaic displaying negative genetic interference. J Virol83, 3127–3137.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Nagy, P. D. & Simon, A. E.(1997). New insights into the mechanisms of RNA recombination. Virology235, 1–9.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Reuter, G., Vennema, H., Koopmans, M. & Szucs, G.(2006). Epidemic spread of recombinant noroviruses with four capsid types in Hungary. J Clin Virol35, 84–88.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Scipioni, A., Mauroy, A., Vinje, J. & Thiry, E.(2008). Animal noroviruses. Vet J178, 32–45.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Simmonds, P., Karakasiliotis, I., Bailey, D., Chaudhry, Y., Evans, D. J. & Goodfellow, I. G.(2008). Bioinformatic and functional analysis of RNA secondary structure elements among different genera of human and animal caliciviruses. Nucleic Acids Res36, 2530–2546.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Sosnovtsev, S. V., Belliot, G., Chang, K. O., Prikhodko, V. G., Thackray, L. B., Wobus, C. E., Karst, S. M., Virgin, H. W., IV & Green, K. Y.(2006). Cleavage map and proteolytic processing of the murine norovirus nonstructural polyprotein in infected cells. J Virol80, 7816–7831.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Spann, K. M., Collins, P. L. & Teng, M. N.(2003). Genetic recombination during coinfection of two mutants of human respiratory syncytial virus. J Virol77, 11201–11211.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Thackray, L. B., Wobus, C. E., Chachu, K. A., Liu, B., Alegre, E. R., Henderson, K. S., Kelley, S. T. & Virgin, H. W., IV(2007). Murine noroviruses comprising a single genogroup exhibit biological diversity despite limited sequence divergence. J Virol81, 10460–10473.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Thiry, E., Meurens, F., Muylkens, B., McVoy, M., Gogev, S., Thiry, J., Vanderplasschen, A., Epstein, A., Keil, G. & Schynts, F.(2005). Recombination in alphaherpesviruses. Rev Med Virol15, 89–103.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Tolskaya, E. A., Romanova, L. I., Blinov, V. M., Viktorova, E. G., Sinyakov, A. N., Kolesnikova, M. S. & Agol, V. I.(1987). Studies on the recombination between RNA genomes of poliovirus: the primary structure and nonrandom distribution of crossover regions in the genomes of intertypic poliovirus recombinants. Virology161, 54–61.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Vende, P., Le Gall, G. & Rasschaert, D.(1995). An alternative method for direct sequencing of PCR products, for epidemiological studies performed by nucleic sequence comparison. Application to rabbit haemorrhagic disease virus. Vet Res26, 174–179.
[Google Scholar]
Wobus, C. E., Karst, S. M., Thackray, L. B., Chang, K. O., Sosnovtsev, S. V., Belliot, G., Krug, A., Mackenzie, J. M., Green, K. Y. & Virgin, H. W., IV(2004). Replication of Norovirus in cell culture reveals a tropism for dendritic cells and macrophages. PLoS Biol2, e432.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Wobus, C. E., Thackray, L. B. & Virgin, H. W., IV(2006). Murine norovirus: a model system to study norovirus biology and pathogenesis. J Virol80, 5104–5112.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Worobey, M. & Holmes, E. C.(1999). Evolutionary aspects of recombination in RNA viruses. J Gen Virol80, 2535–2543.
[Google Scholar]
Zheng, D. P., Ando, T., Fankhauser, R. L., Beard, R. S., Glass, R. I. & Monroe, S. S.(2006). Norovirus classification and proposed strain nomenclature. Virology346, 312–323.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]