Advantages of multilocus sequence analysis for taxonomic studies: a case study using 10 housekeeping genes in the genus Ensifer (including former Sinorhizobium)
There is a need for easy, practical, reliable and robust techniques for the identification and classification of bacterial isolates to the species level as alternatives to 16S rRNA gene sequence analysis and DNA–DNA hybridization. Here, we demonstrate that multilocus sequence analysis (MLSA) of housekeeping genes is a valuable alternative technique. An MLSA study of 10 housekeeping genes (atpD, dnaK, gap, glnA, gltA, gyrB, pnp, recA, rpoB and thrC) was performed on 34 representatives of the genus Ensifer. Genetic analysis and comparison with 16S and 23S rRNA gene sequences demonstrated clear species boundaries and a higher discrimination potential for all housekeeping genes. Comparison of housekeeping gene sequence data with DNA–DNA reassociation data revealed good correlation at the intraspecies level, but indicated that housekeeping gene sequencing is superior to DNA–DNA hybridization for the assessment of genetic relatedness between Ensifer species. Our MLSA data, confirmed by DNA–DNA hybridizations, support the suggestion that Ensifer xinjiangensis is a later heterotypic synonym of Ensifer fredii.
Acinas, S. G., Marcelino, L. A., Klepac-Ceraj, V. & Polz, M. F.(2004). Divergence and redundancy of 16S rRNA sequences in genomes with multiple rrn operons. J Bacteriol186, 2629–2635.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Adekambi, T. & Drancourt, M.(2004). Dissection of phylogenetic relationships among 19 rapidly growing Mycobacterium species by 16S rRNA, hsp65, sodA, recA and rpoB gene sequencing. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol54, 2095–2105.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Altschul, S. F., Madden, T. L., Schaffer, A. A., Zhang, J., Zhang, Z., Miller, W. & Lipman, D. J.(1997). Gapped blast and psi-blast: a new generation of protein database search programs. Nucleic Acids Res25, 3389–3402.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Amann, R. I., Lin, C. H., Key, R., Montgomery, L. & Stahl, D. A.(1992). Diversity among Fibrobacter strains: towards a phylogenetic classification. Syst Appl Microbiol15, 23–32.
[Google Scholar]
Baele, M., Baele, P., Vaneechoutte, M., Storms, V., Butaye, P., Devriese, L. A., Verschraegen, G., Gillis, M. & Haesebrouck, F.(2000). Application of tRNA intergenic spacer PCR for identification of Enterococcus species. J Clin Microbiol38, 4201–4207.
[Google Scholar]
Charles, L., Carbone, I., Davies, K. G., Bird, D., Burke, M., Kerry, B. R. & Opperman, C. H.(2005). Phylogenetic analysis of Pasteuria penetrans by use of multiple genetic loci. J Bacteriol187, 5700–5708.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Cho, J. C. & Tiedje, J. M.(2001). Bacterial species determination from DNA-DNA hybridization by using genome fragments and DNA microarrays. Appl Environ Microbiol67, 3677–3682.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Christensen, H. & Olsen, J. E.(1998). Phylogenetic relationships of Salmonella based on DNA sequence comparison of atpD encoding the beta subunit of ATP synthase. FEMS Microbiol Lett161, 89–96.
[Google Scholar]
Christensen, H., Kuhnert, P., Olsen, J. E. & Bisgaard, M.(2004). Comparative phylogenies of the housekeeping genes atpD, infB and rpoB and the 16S rRNA gene within the Pasteurellaceae. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol54, 1601–1609.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Coenye, T., Gevers, D., Van de Peer, Y., Vandamme, P. & Swings, J.(2005). Towards a prokaryotic genomic taxonomy. FEMS Microbiol Rev29, 147–167.
[Google Scholar]
de Lajudie, P., Willems, A., Pot, B., Dewettinck, D., Maestrojuan, G., Neyra, M., Collins, M. D., Dreyfus, B., Kersters, K. & Gillis, M.(1994). Polyphasic taxonomy of rhizobia – emendation of the genus Sinorhizobium and description of Sinorhizobium meliloti comb. nov., Sinorhizobium saheli sp. nov. and Sinorhizobium terangae sp. nov. Int J Syst Bacteriol44, 715–733.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
DelVecchio, V. G., Kapatral, V., Redkar, R. J., Patra, G., Mujer, C., Los, T., Ivanova, N., Anderson, I., Bhattacharyya, A. & other authors(2002). The genome sequence of the facultative intracellular pathogen Brucella melitensis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A99, 443–448.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Euzéby, J. P. & Tindall, B. J.(2004). Status of strains that contravene Rules 27(3) and 30 of the Bacteriological Code. Request for an Opinion. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol54, 293–301.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Ezaki, T., Hashimoto, Y. & Yabuuchi, E.(1989). Fluorometric deoxyribonucleic acid-deoxyribonucleic acid hybridization in microdilution wells as an alternative to membrane filter hybridization in which radioisotopes are used to determine genetic relatedness among bacterial strains. Int J Syst Bacteriol39, 224–229.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Farris, J. S., Kallersjo, M., Kluge, A. G. & Bult, C.(1995). Constructing a significance test for incongruence. Syst Biol44, 570–572.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Fox, G. E., Wisotzkey, J. D. & Jurtshuk, P., Jr(1992). How close is close: 16S ribosomal RNA sequence identity may not be sufficient to guarantee species identity. Int J Syst Bacteriol42, 166–170.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Galibert, F., Finan, T. M., Long, S. R., Puhler, A., Abola, P., Ampe, F., Barloy-Hubler, F., Barnett, M. J., Becker, A. & other authors(2001). The composite genome of the legume symbiont Sinorhizobium meliloti. Science293, 668–672.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Gevers, D., Cohan, F. M., Lawrence, J. G., Spratt, B. G., Coenye, T., Feil, E. J., Stackebrandt, E., Van de Peer, Y., Vandamme, P. & other authors(2005). Re-evaluating prokaryotic species. Nat Rev Microbiol3, 733–739.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Goodfellow, M., Manfio, G. P. & Chun, J.(1997). Towards a practical species concept for cultivable bacteria. In Species: the Units of Biodiversity, pp. 25–59. Edited by M. F. Claridge & H. A. Dawah. London: Chapman & Hall.
Goodner, B., Hinkle, G., Gattung, S., Miller, N., Blanchard, M., Qurollo, B., Goldman, B. S., Cao, Y., Askenazi, M. & other authors(2001). Genome sequence of the plant pathogen and biotechnology agent Agrobacterium tumefaciens C58. Science294, 2323–2328.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Goris, J., Konstantinidis, K. T., Klappenbach, J. A., Coenye, T., Vandamme, P. & Tiedje, J. M.(2007). DNA–DNA hybridization values and their relationship to whole-genome sequence similarities. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol57, 81–91.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Holmes, D. E., Nevin, K. P. & Lovley, D. R.(2004). Comparison of 16S rRNA, nifD, recA, gyrB, rpoB and fusA genes within the family Geobacteraceae fam. nov. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol54, 1591–1599.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Jaspers, E. & Overmann, J.(2004). Ecological significance of microdiversity: identical 16S rRNA gene sequences can be found in bacteria with highly divergent genomes and ecophysiologies. Appl Environ Microbiol70, 4831–4839.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Kaneko, T., Nakamura, Y., Sato, S., Asamizu, E., Kato, T., Sasamoto, S., Watanabe, A., Idesawa, K., Ishikawa, K. & other authors(2000). Complete genome structure of the nitrogen-fixing symbiotic bacterium Mesorhizobium loti. DNA Res7, 331–338.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Kaneko, T., Nakamura, Y., Sato, S., Minamisawa, K., Uchiumi, T., Sasamoto, S., Watanabe, A., Idesawa, K., Iriguchi, M. & other authors(2002). Complete genomic sequence of nitrogen-fixing symbiotic bacterium Bradyrhizobium japonicum USDA110. DNA Res9, 189–197.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Konstantinidis, K. T. & Tiedje, J. M.(2005). Genomic insights that advance the species definition for prokaryotes. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A102, 2567–2572.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Konstantinidis, K. T., Ramette, A. & Tiedje, J. M.(2006). Toward a more robust assessment of intraspecies diversity, using fewer genetic markers. Appl Environ Microbiol72, 7286–7293.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Kwon, S. W., Park, J. Y., Kim, J. S., Kang, J. W., Cho, Y. H., Lim, C. K., Parker, M. A. & Lee, G. B.(2005). Phylogenetic analysis of the genera Bradyrhizobium, Mesorhizobium, Rhizobium and Sinorhizobium on the basis of 16S rRNA gene and internally transcribed spacer region sequences. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol55, 263–270.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Larimer, F. W., Chain, P., Hauser, L., Lamerdin, J., Malfatti, S., Do, L., Land, M. L., Pelletier, D. A., Beatty, J. T. & other authors(2004). Complete genome sequence of the metabolically versatile photosynthetic bacterium Rhodopseudomonas palustris. Nat Biotechnol22, 55–61.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Maiden, M. C. J., Bygraves, J. A., Feil, E., Morelli, G., Russell, J. E., Urwin, R., Zhang, Q., Zhou, J. J., Zurth, K. & other authors(1998). Multilocus sequence typing: a portable approach to the identification of clones within populations of pathogenic microorganisms. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A95, 3140–3145.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Marmur, J.(1961). A procedure for the isolation of deoxyribonucleic acid from microorganisms. J Mol Biol3, 208–218.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Martens, M., Delaere, M., Coopman, R., De Vos, P., Gillis, M. & Willems, A.(2007). Multilocus sequence analysis of Ensifer and related taxa. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol57, 489–503.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Mollet, C., Drancourt, M. & Raoult, D.(1997).rpoB sequence analysis as a novel basis for bacterial identification. Mol Microbiol26, 1005–1011.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Naser, S. M., Thompson, F. L., Hoste, B., Gevers, D., Dawyndt, P., Vancanneyt, M. & Swings, J.(2005). Application of multilocus sequence analysis (MLSA) for rapid identification of Enterococcus species based on rpoA and pheS genes. Microbiology151, 2141–2150.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Naser, S. M., Dawyndt, P., Hoste, B., Gevers, D., Vandemeulebroecke, K., Cleenwerck, I., Vancanneyt, M. & Swings, J.(2007). Identification of lactobacilli by pheS and rpoA gene sequence analyses. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol57, 2777–2789.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Nick, G., Jussila, M., Hoste, B., Niemi, R. M., Kaijalainen, S., de Lajudie, P., Gillis, M., de Bruijn, F. J. & Lindström, K.(1999). Rhizobia isolated from root nodules of tropical leguminous trees characterized using DNA-DNA dot-blot hybridisation and rep-PCR genomic fingerprinting. Syst Appl Microbiol22, 287–299.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Nierman, W. C., Feldblyum, T. V., Laub, M. T., Paulsen, I. T., Nelson, K. E., Eisen, J., Heidelberg, J. F., Alley, M. R. K., Ohta, N. & other authors(2001). Complete genome sequence of Caulobacter crescentus. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A98, 4136–4141.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Nørskov-Lauritsen, N., Bruun, B. & Kilian, M.(2005). Multilocus sequence phylogenetic study of the genus Haemophilus with description of Haemophilus pittmaniae sp. nov. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol55, 449–456.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Owen, R. J. & Pitcher, D.(1983). Current methods for determining DNA-base composition and levels of DNA-DNA hybridization. J Appl Bacteriol55, R16–R16.
[Google Scholar]
Paulsen, I. T., Seshadri, R., Nelson, K. E., Eisen, J. A., Heidelberg, J. F., Read, T. D., Dodson, R. J., Umayam, L., Brinkac, L. M. & other authors(2002). The Brucella suis genome reveals fundamental similarities between animal and plant pathogens and symbionts. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A99, 13148–13153.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Peng, G. X., Tan, Z. Y., Wang, E. T., Reinhold-Hurek, B., Chen, W. F. & Chen, W. X.(2002). Identification of isolates from soybean nodules in Xinjiang Region as Sinorhizobium xinjiangense and genetic differentiation of S. xinjiangense from Sinorhizobium fredii. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol52, 457–462.
[Google Scholar]
Posada, D. & Buckley, T. R.(2004). Model selection and model averaging in phylogenetics: advantages of Akaike information criterion and Bayesian approaches over likelihood ratio tests. Syst Biol53, 793–808.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Posada, D. & Crandall, K. A.(1998).modeltest: testing the model of DNA substitution. Bioinformatics14, 817–818.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Rokas, A., King, N., Finnerty, J. & Carroll, S. B.(2003). Conflicting phylogenetic signals at the base of the metazoan tree. Evol Dev5, 346–359.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Rönner, S., Liesack, W., Wolters, J. & Stackebrandt, E.(1991). Cloning and sequencing of a large fragment of the atpD gene of Pirellula marina – a contribution to the phylogeny of Planctomycetales. Endocytobiosis Cell Res7, 219–229.
[Google Scholar]
Rosselló-Mora, R.(2006). DNA-DNA reassociation methods applied to microbial taxonomy and their critical evaluation. In Molecular Identification, Systematics, and Population Structure of Prokaryotes, pp. 23–50. Edited by E. Stackebrandt. Heidelberg: Springer.
Selenska-Pobell, S. & Evguenieva-Hackenberg, E.(1995). Fragmentations of the large-subunit rRNA in the family Rhizobiaceae. J Bacteriol177, 6993–6998.
[Google Scholar]
Stackebrandt, E. & Goebel, B. M.(1994). Taxonomic note: a place for DNA-DNA reassociation and 16S rRNA sequence analysis in the present species definition in bacteriology. Int J Syst Bacteriol44, 846–849.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Stackebrandt, E., Frederiksen, W., Garrity, G. M., Grimont, P. A., Kämpfer, P., Maiden, M. C. J., Nesme, X., Rosselló-Mora, R., Swings, J. & other authors(2002). Report of the ad hoc committee for the re-evaluation of the species definition in bacteriology. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol52, 1043–1047.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Stackebrandt, E., Päuker, O., Steiner, U., Schumann, P., Sträubler, B., Heibei, S. & Lang, E.(2007). Taxonomic characterization of members of the genus Corallococcus: molecular divergence versus phenotypic coherency. Syst Appl Microbiol30, 109–118.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Sullivan, J. T., Eardly, B. D., van Berkum, P. & Ronson, C. W.(1996). Four unnamed species of nonsymbiotic rhizobia isolated from the rhizosphere of Lotus corniculatus. Appl Environ Microbiol62, 2818–2825.
[Google Scholar]
Swofford, D. L.(2002).paup*: phylogenetic analysis using parsimony (and other methods), version 4. Sunderland, MA: Sinauer Associates.
Tan, Z. Y., Xu, X. D., Wang, E. T., Gag, J. L., Martínez-Romero, E. & Chen, W. X.(1997). Phylogenetic and genetic relationships of Mesorhizobium tianshanense and related rhizobia. Int J Syst Bacteriol47, 874–879.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Thompson, J. D., Gibson, T. J., Plewniak, F., Jeanmougin, F. & Higgins, D. G.(1997). The clustal_x windows interface: flexible strategies for multiple sequence alignment aided by quality analysis tools. Nucleic Acids Res25, 4876–4882.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Thompson, F. L., Gevers, D., Thompson, C. C., Dawyndt, P., Naser, S., Hoste, B., Munn, C. B. & Swings, J.(2005). Phylogeny and molecular identification of vibrios on the basis of multilocus sequence analysis. Appl Environ Microbiol71, 5107–5115.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Toledo, I., Lloret, L. & Martínez-Romero, E.(2003).Sinorhizobium americanum sp. nov., a new Sinorhizobium species nodulating native Acacia spp. in Mexico. Syst Appl Microbiol26, 54–64.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Turner, S. L., Zhang, X.-X., Li, F.-D. & Young, J. P. W.(2002). What does a bacterial genome sequence represent? Mis-assignment of MAFF 303099 to the genospecies Mesorhizobium loti. Microbiology148, 3330–3331.
[Google Scholar]
Van Camp, G., Chapelle, S. & De Wachter, R.(1993). Amplification and sequencing of variable regions in bacterial 23S ribosomal RNA genes with conserved primer sequences. Curr Microbiol27, 147–151.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Wang, E. T., Tan, Z. Y., Willems, A., Fernández-López, M., Reinhold-Hurek, B. & Martínez-Romero, E.(2002).Sinorhizobium morelense sp nov., a Leucaena leucocephala-associated bacterium that is highly resistant to multiple antibiotics. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol52, 1687–1693.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Wayne, L. G., Brenner, D. J., Colwell, R. R., Grimont, P. A. D., Kandler, O., Krichevsky, M. I., Moore, L. H., Moore, W. E. C., Murray, R. G. E. & other authors(1987). International Committee on Systematic Bacteriology. Report of the ad hoc committee on reconciliation of approaches to bacterial systematics. Int J Syst Bacteriol37, 463–464.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Wernersson, R. & Pedersen, A. G.(2003). RevTrans: multiple alignment of coding DNA from aligned amino acid sequences. Nucleic Acids Res31, 3537–3539.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Wertz, J. E., Goldstone, C., Gordon, D. M. & Riley, M. A.(2003). A molecular phylogeny of enteric bacteria and implications for a bacterial species concept. J Evol Biol16, 1236–1248.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Willems, A., Doignon-Bourcier, F., Goris, J., Coopman, R., de Lajudie, P., De Vos, P. & Gillis, M.(2001). DNA–DNA hybridization study of Bradyrhizobium strains. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol51, 1315–1322.
[Google Scholar]
Willems, A., Fernández-López, M., Muñoz-Adelantado, E., Goris, J., De Vos, P., Martínez-Romero, E., Toro, N. & Gillis, M.(2003). Description of new Ensifer strains from nodules and proposal to transfer Ensifer adhaerens Casida 1982 to Sinorhizobium as Sinorhizobium adhaerens comb. nov. Request for an Opinion. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol53, 1207–1217.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Woese, C. R.(1987). Bacterial evolution. Microbiol Rev51, 221–271.
[Google Scholar]
Wood, D. W., Setubal, J. C., Kaul, R., Monks, D. E., Kitajima, J. P., Okura, V. K., Zhou, Y., Chen, L., Wood, G. E. & other authors(2001). The genome of the natural genetic engineer Agrobacterium tumefaciens C58. Science294, 2317–2323.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Yamamoto, S. & Harayama, S.(1995). PCR amplification and direct sequencing of gyrB genes with universal primers and their application to the detection and taxonomic analysis of Pseudomonas putida strains. Appl Environ Microbiol61, 1104–1109.
[Google Scholar]
Yamamoto, S., Bouvet, P. J. M. & Harayama, S.(1999). Phylogenetic structures of the genus Acinetobacter based on gyrB sequences: comparison with the grouping by DNA–DNA hybridization. Int J Syst Bacteriol49, 87–95.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Young, J. M.(2003). The genus name Ensifer Casida 1982 takes priority over Sinorhizobium Chen et al. 1988, and Sinorhizobium morelense Wang et al. 2002 is a later synonym of Ensifer adhaerens Casida 1982. Is the combination ‘Sinorhizobium adhaerens’ (Casida 1982) Willems et al. 2003 legitimate? Request for an Opinion. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol53, 2107–2110.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Zeigler, D. R.(2003). Gene sequences useful for predicting relatedness of whole genomes in bacteria. Int J Syst Evol Microbiol53, 1893–1900.[CrossRef][Google Scholar]
Advantages of multilocus sequence analysis for taxonomic studies: a case study using 10 housekeeping genes in the genus Ensifer (including former Sinorhizobium)